Now playing

Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

Longacre Theatre · opened Nov 2025

*Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)* is an original, new musical comedy about two ordinary people, a cheery Brit and a lifelong New Yorker, who go on a city adventure and spark a connection along the way.

For theater lovers
Earnest, demanding theater fans
0 reviews
For concert goers
Came for the music
0 reviews
For people who hate plays
Bring on the songs
0 reviews
For people who hate musicals
Came in skeptical
0 reviews

Buy tickets

3 channels

Best price right now

Other options
$101–$10740% off
7:30 PM · In-person same-day only
TDF TKTS Booth

How easy are tickets?

83.1% full

Limited

Single seats around the house.

Weekly gross
$653,362
Avg ticket
$94
Seats sold
6,959
Performances
8
Change vs prior week
+5.9pp capacity

Where to sit

Crowd-sourced seat tips for Longacre Theatre — sightlines, legroom, big-and-tall friendliness.

No seat tips for Longacre Theatre yet. If you’ve sat here, leave a tip — sightlines, legroom, whether your 6’4" cousin would fit.

Cast & creative

From IBDB · 2 cast · 63 creative

Opening-night cast

  • Christiani Pittsas Robin
  • Sam Tuttyas DougalDebut

Creative team

Lead Producer: Kevin McCollum , Tim Johanson , Glass Half Full Productions and Jamie Wilson Productions ; Co-Produced
Kevin McCollum,Tim Johanson,Glass Half Full Productions,Jamie Wilson Productions,Evan McGill,Dennis Trunfio,Abrams Corr Riemer Productions,Marc David Levine & Stephen S. Miller,Laura Lonergan,James L. Nederlander,Michael Patrick & Paul Gavriani,Merrie L. Davis / Tony Spinosa & Barbara Gallay,Walport Productions,Agrawal & PBT / JKDNV Productions,Aleff & Nothing Ventured / Flatto Turchin
Book
Jim Barne,Kit Buchan,Lux Pyramid,Ted Arthur
Directed
Tim Jackson,Asmeret Ghebremichael
Scenic Design
Soutra Gilmour,Jack Knowles,Tony Gayle,Cheryl Thomas,Brian Webb,Ricky Lurie,Jessica Creager,Kirk Fitzgerald,Cody Spencer,Lily Tomasic,Jess Gersz,Hope Debelius,Sumner Ellsworth
General Manager
Theater Matters,John E. Gendron,Ashley Berman,Eric Rothstein,Michelle Yard
Production Manager
Hudson Theatrical Associates,Judith Schoenfeld,Alfredo Macias,Thea McRae
Musical Supervisor: Nick Finlow ; Music Production: Lux Pyramid ; Musical Coordinator: John Miller ; Conducted
Nick Finlow,Lux Pyramid,John Miller,Ted Arthur,Kevin Ramessar,Lee Nadel,Rocky Bryant,Jessie Linden,Randy Cohen,Randy Cohen Keyboards,Utsav Bhargava,Chris Guard
Original UK Casting
Julia Horan CDG,C12 Casting,Stephen Kopel, CSA,The Pekoe Group,Vivacity Media Group,Phoenix Best,Matthew Murphy,Evan Zimmerman

Source: ibdb.com · scraped via the auto-build pipeline. Names + roles as IBDB labels them.

All reviews (0)

No published reviews yet. Once the first reviewer rants, scores show up here.
Tickets

Affiliate links and seat-intel land here. We'll never run an ad for a show whose score we can't honestly show alongside it.